Four different questions. Bio-based describes the feedstock the carbon came from. Degradable means it will break down eventually, with no defined conditions. Compostable means it meets a named standard under defined conditions — EN 13432 industrial: 58 °C, 90% biodegradation within six months. Recyclable means it enters existing collection and sorting and is graded under PPWR Article 6. Bio-based does not imply degradable; compostable does not imply recyclable.
Bio-based is only about the origin of the carbon. Bio-PE made from sugar-cane ethanol is chemically identical to petrochemical PE and does not biodegrade at all. PBAT is fossil-based and passes EN 13432. The label says nothing about end of life, and nothing about safety.
In engineering terms “degradable” is close to meaningless: any material degrades given enough time, heat or UV. That is why the EU listed “degradable”, “bio-based” and “eco-friendly” in the generic-claims blacklist at Annex I of Directive (EU) 2024/825, applicable from 27 September 2026 — using them in consumer-facing communication without recognised excellent environmental performance is treated as a misleading practice.
Compostability is a testable specification. EN 13432 requires 58 ± 2 °C, 90% biodegradation within six months, 90% disintegration through a 2 mm sieve within 12 weeks, plus heavy-metal and ecotoxicity limits. Home composting is a separate regime (20–30 °C, 12 months) and one certificate cannot stand in for the other.
Compostable and recyclable often pull against each other: compostable material in a plastics recycling stream is a contaminant. PPWR Article 6 grades a packaging unit by the recyclable share of its weight — A ≥ 95%, B ≥ 80%, C ≥ 70% — with the C floor applying from 2030. Quote the standard number and the test conditions; adjectives do not survive an audit.
| Bio-based | Feedstock carbon source only — bio-PE does not biodegrade |
|---|---|
| Degradable | No defined test; generic use restricted in EU consumer claims |
| Industrial compostable | EN 13432: 58 °C, 90% biodegradation in 6 months |
| Home compostable | OK Compost HOME / NF T51-800: 20–30 °C, 90% in 12 months |
| Recyclable | PPWR Art. 6: A ≥ 95% / B ≥ 80% / C ≥ 70% |