Decide on three properties: fibre aspect ratio, ash and silica content, and supply stability. Bamboo fibre is long and slender — close to hardwood, below softwood — so it reinforces more effectively per unit load. Straw and rice husk carry high ash and silica, which abrades tooling and complicates pulping liquor recovery. Wood is the most standardised. Load-bearing parts and film: bamboo. Cheap filler: residue.
Silica is bamboo's known weakness in pulping and pyrolysis: scaling in the recovery system, faster wear on dies, screws and pipework. The offset is aspect ratio — at equal loading, bamboo gives better flexural strength and puncture resistance than wood flour, so performance targets are easier to hit.
Straw and husk are seasonal, have a short collection radius and high ash (rice husk can reach 15–20%). They suit local filler or energy recovery, not long-haul high-value fibre. In film, contaminants and coarse particles raise breakage rates sharply.
Wood wins on standardisation: stable fibre morphology, controlled moisture, mature grading and pricing. It loses on rotation length, and on the due-diligence paperwork that attaches to wood-based supply chains in the EU. Bamboo sits outside that classification, which is a practical advantage in tenders.
Three questions settle it: does the part carry load (yes → bamboo or wood fibre); what cost can the product absorb (tight → residue filler); what does the buyer audit (batch consistency → wood; bio-based content and story → bamboo). Never decide on a resin-replacement price comparison alone.